But what about the ink?

A new book about pens is heavy on anecdote and light on context

A rectangle with a maroon background and a cover image of Simon Garfield's The Pen, in which the title is written in flowing calligraphy with an illustrated pen connected to the P.
Editor's note: Links to bookshop.org are affiliate links.

Simon Garfield, The Pen: A Human History. Crown, November 2026.

It seems unlikely that anyone picking up Simon Garfield’s new book, The Pen, is agnostic about pens. I did a quick poll at work to see how many of us were Pen Casual, Pen Preferential, or Pen Bananas (my categories). Perhaps, as one of my colleagues noted, the results were unsurprising: “This just in: the special collections library has a lot of people who are kind of intense about writing implements.” For me, it’s almost always a medium ball point with a spongy grip—the Pilot Dr. Grip—or a LAMY fountain pen first given to me by an extraordinary writer (which I still imagine will give me a shimmer of her luminous prose). In the book, Garfield refers to this LAMY Safari as “factory-turned” but also “stylish” (an adjective that has to accrue to my benefactor, not me). 

Garfield is the author of a number of books on subjects that one might describe as communication and orientation technologies, including letter writing, GPS, timekeeping, and—my favorite—fonts. Like the pen, these are all objects through which we connect to others across time and space. Mysteriously, however, Garfield’s appealingly told history of the mightiest instrument of human expression is uninterested in those relationships. 

Garfield dips and loops through a loosely chronological history of pens, mostly in the United States but also in Europe. He moves from quills to fountain pens to the ballpoint, with brief pauses for typewriters and the Apple pencil. We learn about advances in pen technology and a host of pen manufacturers, as well as famous moments in pen wielding, often on screen but also in the hands of politicians. 

CTA Image

Never miss a book review. Subscribe to the Drafting the Past newsletter to get updates sent directly to your inbox.

Subscribe

There is a lot of “did you know” material. Presidential signing pens, for example, have been an American tradition since the early 1960s, with presidents using many pens to sign their names to significant documents and then giving them away as mementos. Lyndon Johnson used so many pens (more than 70!) to sign the Civil Rights Act of 1964 that his signature looked like “he wrote it blindfolded, or drunk, or two weeks after he’d learned his alphabet.” Barack Obama used only a handful of ballpoint pens to sign the Lily Ledbetter Fair Pay Act in 2009, but by the time he’d gotten accustomed to the practice, he used almost two dozen Cross rollerballs for the Affordable Care Act in 2010.

Despite this kind of delicious detail, at every page I wanted to pause and ponder the relationship of a pen to its near mates, ink and paper—or to me. Because let’s agree: Pen people are also likely to be ink and paper people.

The Montblanc gets two robust chapters in The Pen. Its famous Meisterstück (“masterpiece”) is the luxury pen that has broken through to the masses, with “an identity unrivaled” among its peers or competitors. It has appeared in films, employed by the rich, powerful, and villainous. Montblanc’s history is a twentieth-century one, boosted early on by the branding talent of Grete Goss—who may have kept company with Nazis. Montblanc’s ascent to iconic status accelerated with the release of limited editions and specialized materials; Garfield’s tantalizing description of the materials in the 2022 Montblanc Mont Blanc (which costs at least $25,000), with its “solid gold skeleton overlay” made of Alpine granite and black onyx, runs to several dozen words.

Despite this kind of delicious detail, at every page I wanted to pause and ponder the relationship of a pen to its near mates, ink and paper. Because let’s agree: Pen people are also likely to be ink and paper people. If it’s iron gall ink that marked a treasured object, it’s probably bothering a conservator as it eats through the smushed linen on which the object is supposed to rest. Coming through my favorite pens, ink could be made of soy or likely petrochemicals, and even if I’m careful it’ll leave a smudge on my fingers. 

But Garfield is not here to talk about the essential goo that makes its mark on the page. He’s really only interested in the instrument. As I read, I tried to stay focused on the thing that offers “the unique adhesion of ink to paper,” the mighty yet appealingly humble pen, but it’s awfully hard not to think about the relationships that pens have with those other materials—and people. A passing reference to the many origins of the fountain pen—“by the time it was invented in Rhode Island in 1876 it was old hat”—prompts a memory: a graduation gift of a gold Cross pen and pencil set, a girly one with floral engraving around the narrow band. 

The Pen is a fun book to read, and I suspect it was an awful lot of fun to research. Even though in some ways the book is a travelog of Garfield’s research, describing his encounters and conversations with pen makers, he can’t ignore all of the relational aspects of pens. When he tells us that the Montegrappa pen company is in Bassano del Grappa, “one of the most romantic places I know,” and that he arrived there with his wife, the train from Venice taking “a little over an hour” on “a crisp sunny day in October of 2024,” we can only wish them well, even as we wish for a few more glimpses like these.

My most practical complaint with The Pen is that I really wanted to see the pens that Garfield was so enthused about. While reading, I spent quite a bit of time searching online for images of pens like the Dickens quill, the black mourning cap that Bics wore for the company founder in 1994 (I never did track this one down), and the Montblanc limited edition homage to Jane Austen (a gorgeous regency blue gray with a gold clip meant to evoke the drawstring on a reticule). And that LBJ signature on the Civil Rights Act of 1964. The Esterbrook dip pens the president used, now in all kinds of collections, look terribly modest in comparison to the job they did.

Pens are objects, but mostly they are instruments. For the intense collectors and hobbyists, a single pen exists as a make, a year, a moment in design and technology. Garfield is not the only one who wants to revel in the material details of pens: The boom in pen hobbyists alongside other analog fandoms has given rise to pen conventions and specialist shops. I wonder whether The Pen—not an especially deep or subtle history but a delightful read—will be a book that real pen devotees buy for themselves, or perhaps to beguile the pen agnostics in their lives.

At the end of The Pen we learn that Garfield wrote the book with his MacBook Air and a suite of pens, with “about a 70-30 split.” Did the pens do the work of outlines or prose, was their ink spilled on a notebook page, or did it just mark revisions on a printout? He does not say, unfortunately. As an instrument for communication, the pen is never singular, ever relative to the inclinations and needs of the human holding it and the world around it. For the record, like Garfield I was bi-modal: I kept notes on The Pen in blue ink in my reading journal, but I produced this text on my MacBook.


Karin Wulf is the Director and Librarian of the John Carter Brown Library, and Professor of History at Brown University. Her latest book is Lineage: Genealogy and the Politics of Connection in Early America, for which she read a lot of manuscripts composed with quill dipped in iron gall ink.

Read More

Subscribe to Drafting the Past

Get new book reviews, craft essays, author Q & As, and more delivered to your inbox.